It doesn’t look like a totally perfect dupe in the picture, and I’ll tell you why. Lipblush by Clinique comes in a screw up applicator that is very prone to drying out. When I wear it or swatch it, it clumps up and the application can be uneven. Also, the lid easily falls off, which causes it to dry out quicker.
Beauty For Real has a very secure lid, and needs to be sharpened, which is awesome, because you can easily get a fresh tip! What I love about Beauty For Real is that this is the only lip pencil they have in their line- they say it matches every lip’s tone and it’s the only liner you’ll ever need. Everything looks great layered over top.